In the statement made on the Competition Authority’s website, information about the investigation was given.
In the statement, it was stated that an investigation was opened to determine whether the companies in question violated the Law on Protection of Competition with their practices regarding the distribution and sale of “product life cycle management” (PLM) software, and that these software consist of technology solutions that allow activities such as industrial design, engineering, analysis, production, product documentation and creation of marketing materials, which are carried out in the process from the idea stage of a product to reaching the end user, to be monitored and managed in the digital environment.
In the statement, it was noted that computer-aided design, production and engineering software are among the common types in the PLM ecosystem, and said, “Siemens offers various software solutions in the field of PLM software, especially Siemens NX, Solid Edge and Teamcenter. The products in question are sold by Siemens directly or through distributors and enterprises that have entered into a dealership agreement with these distributors.” expressions were used.
“WHETHER THERE WAS COORDINATION OR NOT, THE ISSUES WERE EXAMINED”
In the statement where details regarding the preliminary investigation conducted by the Board were shared, the following was noted:
“Within the scope of the preliminary investigation, whether Siemens (the economic entity consisting of Siemens Aktiengesellschaft, Siemens Beteiligungen Europa GmbH and Siemens Industry Software Yazılım Hizmetleri AŞ) imposes customer restrictions on its distributors in direct and indirect sales channels, whether Siemens and Boğaziçi Yazılım apply regional and customer restrictions within the dealership network, whether Siemens and Boğaziçi Yazılım apply dealers’ resale prices. or whether it interfered with the discounts they will offer to end customers, whether Boğaziçi Yazılım’s dealership agreements stipulate non-competition obligations that limit dealers from selling or supporting Siemens’ competing products, whether there is horizontal coordination between Boğaziçi Yazılım and some dealers by offering non-competitive side offers and sharing competitively sensitive information such as offer amounts.”
In the statement, it was stated that the Board found the information, documents and findings obtained in the preliminary investigation serious and sufficient, and said: “Siemens, Boğaziçi Yazılım and Boğaziçi Yazılım dealers Üçgen Yazılım Danışmanlık Bilgisayar ve Makina Sanayi Ticaret Ltd. Şti., BDT Yazılım Ltd. Şti., Biltim Bilgisayar Aided Design and Production Industry and Trade Ltd. Şti., Harun Yılmaz-Nirvana Bilgisayar, Zirve Yazılım Danışmanlık Bilgisayar ve Makina Sanayi Ticaret Ltd. Şti., BCC Yazılım Danışmanlık “It has been decided to open an investigation against Kalıp Makine Sanayi ve Ticaret AŞ and Model Yazılım AŞ.” The expression was used.
On the other hand, the investigation decisions taken by the Board do not mean that the undertakings under investigation have violated the relevant law and are or will face sanctions.